One of the most tired debates that is centered around professional sports, right after the merits of the "hold" statistic, is whether or not players have an obligation to be "role models" and do we, as fans, have the right to expect them to act as such?
Obviously, the media is much more all-emcompassing than it was in the days of, say, Ty Cobb. So the modern fan is more aware of the fact that Jeff Kent has the reputation of being an asshole than the fans during Cobb's era knew of his penchant for being a genuine son of a bitch.
Fans tend to label athletes while only knowing what they read. Or hear. Or see. But what do we really know?
Lou Reed once "sang" (quotes used because he usually "talks" his lyrics), "Don’t believe half of what you see, and none of what you hear."
Me? I usually trust my gut instinct. And that is why...
- Even if Barry Bonds is truly the best homerun hitter of all time, I do not want to see him break Hank Aaron's all-time homerun record. Personally, I think Bonds has set himself up as the "bad guy" on purpose. That way, should he pass Aaron, he can point to all the "adversity" he fought through when his feat is compared to Hank's quest. Sorry, Barry. Not buying it. You prod reporters into conforontations. Aaron got death threats. Will it be long before we hear about Bonds receiving the same? Don't put it past the spin machine.
- I was sorry to hear about the passing of Kirby Puckett. However, it hurt more to hear the allegations of abuse from his ex-wife and the accusation of "groping" from another female a few years ago. He was acquitted on the second, and as far as I know, charges were never brought regarding the first. But those are the types of things that stay in the back of my mind... violence against women by anyone is inexcusible in my mind. Spare me the "innocent until proven guilty" rhetoric. I am, after all, human.
- With that said, I will never forget how Puckett, along with Tony Gwynn, George Brett, and Cal Ripken Jr., embodied 80's baseball to me. His obvious love of the game, infectious smile, and his atypical baseball body were screaming "Market me!" So, yes, yesterday was a sad day for me. I choose to remember the good on this one.
- Notice I left Wade Boggs out of the above trio? That was not by mistake, and remember that I have Red Sox blood in my family.
- With the exception of A-Rod, who I think is about as fake as a placebo drug, I am a big fan of all the players that have opted to participate in the World Baseball Classic out of dedication to their country. And let me say this: Even if USA wins this thing? We, as a country, will still be embarrassed by lack of fan support. I really hope that opens some eyes, too, though I am not holding my breath. Our national pasttime is on the verge of being swept away by other countries that recognize the timeless beauty the game entails. We'll be playing PlayStation. Sad.
So, basically, I have spent all of my time writing this straddling the fence regarding the "role model" vs. "guy doing a job" debate. But I also think that is the way to go. Some players embrace the fact that kids (and, yes, some adults) look up to them while others shun it. Likewise, some fans choose to look the other way regarding athletes while others can't get past character flaws.
If you need to reach me, I'll be here - on the fence. Rooting for my hometeam.